Ice Cream Near Me In Cashiers, North Carolina

Who is Jeni and why we carry Jeni's Ice Cream:

Jeni's Ice Cream

If you’ve searched “Ice Cream Near Me in Cashiers,” Jeni’s Ice Cream at Cream + Flutter is your answer. Starting a few years ago, we realized there weren’t any scoop ice cream shops in Cashiers and set out to change that. At Cream + Flutter we make everything from scratch, except for Jeni’s Ice Cream. We believe in their mission and share their values of quality products and creating great food experiences in community with other people. Jeni’s Ice Cream is a crowd favorite all across the country, but it started in Columbus, Ohio by Jeni Britton Bauer.  Plus, we also started off as a Midwestern company. It was a match made in sweet shop heaven and we’re happy to be your destination next time you type in “Ice Cream Near Me.”

Ways we serve Jeni's ice creams:

French Macaron Ice Cream.jpg

We all have our own way of eating ice cream, so we made sure you have everything you need to make your perfect ice cream creation in Cashiers. First off, you can have your ice cream in the form of scoops, milkshakes, sundaes, pints, Street Treats (which are individual cups of ice cream), and we even have mini cones for kids! Then once you’ve got the form and flavor (our favorites listed below), you can add a multitude of toppings that range from shots of espresso to chocolate crispy pearls.

Cashiers local favorite flavors: 

These are the show stoppers that if we don’t have stocked, riots ensue. We’ve included the Jeni’s description for your convenience! Plus check out the 5 Cream + Flutter Cashiers Items You Need Try This Summer for more delicious options.

Brown Butter Almond Brittle - Brown-butter-almond candy crushed into buttermilk ice cream. Made with rich buttermilk ice cream and golden pockets of handmade almond brittle, this sweet, salty, crunchy ice cream quickly became a menu mainstay.

Honey Vanilla Bean - A vanilla to end all vanillas. Made with Fair Trade vanilla beans that are warm and complex in flavor and a perfect partner for a touch of honey and grass-grazed milk.

Darkest Chocolate - Mouth-filling and palate-gripping with a pleasingly dry finish. The most amount of Fair Trade cocoa and the least amount of anything else.

Salty Caramel - Fire-toasted sugar with sea salt, vanilla, and grass-grazed milk. A perfect balance of salty and sweet.

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks - Salted and roasted ground peanuts with grass-grazed milk and crunchy, dark chocolate flecks.

Gooey Butter Cake - Cream cheese ice cream layered with crumbles of soft vanilla cake and swirls of made-from-scratch caramel-butterscotch sauce.

Staff Favorites:

Amanda: I like to eat ice cream cones with my kids.  We always stuff the inside of a cone with one flavor and then top it with a second flavor.  The stuffed cone is key. My 4 year old loves Super Moon and Rainbow BFY topped with gummy bears. 

Cream + Flutter Ice Cream

Whitney: Milkshakes!  Favorite combo is brambleberry crisp with white chocolate crispy pearls.  

Mandy: Favorite is salty caramel topped with candied pecans.

Emily: Likes to scoop darkest chocolate ice cream and frosé into a bowl and then break a cone apart and eat the ice cream like "chips and dip"

Etta: Loves salty caramel topped with two shots of espresso!

Ice Cream in Cashiers Just Got That Much Better

Jeni's Ice Cream

On Fridays in season (Memorial Day to Labor Day), we also serve ice cream at Groovin' on the Green, Cashiers summer concert series featuring a variety of local and regional musicians playing at The Village Green Commons. 

We have a big community table inside our retail space and we also have several bistro tables and chairs outside in front of our store. A lot of people in Cashiers want to eat outside because the weather is so beautiful and that should be just as true when it comes to ice cream. Come on by in the day or in the evenings. We’re just down the strip from the amazing Slab Town Pizza and get a lot of guests who are looking to end their night with ice cream in Cashiers. Pizza + Jeni’s Ice Cream, say no more. Looking for more to do in Cashiers? Check out 5 Cream + Flutter Cashiers Items You Need Try This Summer.


Amanda Wyatt