Daily walk-in Menu

Cupcakes

Each Cream & Flutter pastry is made from scratch using only the best ingredients, including French chocolates and cocoa powders, creamy European-style butters, and pure extracts and fruit oils, as well as fresh, natural dairy products and eggs from local farms. Balancing innovative, seasonal flavor combinations with approachable homespun comfort, Cream & Flutter completely redefines the standard for cupcakes. Walk in daily for signature red velvet, chocolate, and vanilla, plus two unique seasonal options, switched the first Monday of each month. We can offer gluten free cupcakes as a custom order, minimum quantity 1 dozen.

Any of our cupcakes can also be ordered as minis by the dozen to cater events! Just give us a call 2-3 days before your date.

Pinwheel French Macarons

Our pinwheel French macarons are beloved for their pretty shapes and fun flavors! See our seasonal flavors table (below on this page) to check when your favorites will be available. We can also make traditional smaller French macarons by the dozens as a custom order!

Homestyle Cookies

We bake huge homemade cookies fresh each morning for our customers to walk in and purchase from our display. We also make these same flavors available to order in larger quantities, or as mini cookies sold by the dozens.  Mini cookies are a great way to feed a big crowd on a limited budget: order from a wide selection of flavors  we have something for everyone!

Signature and Seasonal Brownies

Our deliciously dark chocolate brownies are generously sized -- perfect for an individual indulgence or to share with a friend! Look for special seasonal brownies in the Fall (S'mores) and around the holiday season (Dark Chocolate Peppermint).  Brownies can also be made as brownie bites for party and event catering - just give us a call 2-3 days before your event!

Ice Cream

We have scoops and pints of super premium ice cream available all year long and feature a rotating menu of flavors from our ice cream partners: Jenis' Splendid Ice Creams and Graeter's Ice Creams. We also make our own in-house ice cream products which are available seasonally.  Cream & Flutter ice cream sandwiches and ice cream cupcakes are produced from a homemade custard base made featuring Kilgus Farmstead milks and creams, as well as our high-quality mix-ins and extracts.  These single serving ice cream products are available in our retail freezer from April through September.  

Gourmet candies

For candy lovers of all ages!  We import our colorful, unique, and delicious candies from all the way across the pond.  These timeless, yet trendy, British sweets make fabulous gifts and even better wedding and party favors.  Buy them in bulk for candy and dessert tables!  We also love our oversized, pillowy marshmallow selection and soft, chewy caramels from Little Flower Company in California.  These marshmallows and caramels are delicious confections still made by hand, with care, using pure, simple ingredients!

Catering & special events

In addition to weddings, Cream & Flutter offers a distinctive selection of desserts for catering and other special events.  We work with many individuals to host baby showers, bridal showers, and birthday parties.  We also partner with many corporate clients and organizations such as local businesses, sororities, and non-profits, to help promote new products, welcome new members, or raise funds for good causes.

Our goal is to make it easy for you to throw a fabulous party!  All of the signature products you see available daily in our shop can be made in both single-serving and mini sizes and are easy to order in person or over the phone.  We can also customize products with logos or to match party decor and are happy to produce out of season favorites with a minimum order.  Delivery is available locally and we also offer stand rental in some circumstances.

Dessert tables can also be a fun, interactive choice for a special event.  All product is produced in bite sized proportions, making it easy for guests to enjoy dessert without forks or complicated serving requirements.  And to make your life easy, we sell our fully-designed dessert tables in packages that include all of the product and services necessary to feed a specific number of guests - with absolutely no hassle on your part! 

Dessert tables are available starting at 100 guests, and include a selection of our most popular mini bites, stand rental, signage, delivery, setup, and stand pickup the following day.  We build and price our tables based on three mini pieces of dessert per person.  Dessert tables are designed to encourage guests to try multiple dessert types and flavors and we find that this estimate works well for most events.   

If you are looking for help with products for catering or special events, please call our shop at (217) 355-5400 and speak with someone from our customer service team.  They can get you started with pricing and product options!

Seasonal Products By Month

This table will let you know when to expect your favorite products in-store. These are the seasonal flavors we feature, in addition to the signature flavors we always have available. We switch all flavors on the Monday closest to the first of each new month. Any flavor can be ordered at any time of the year, even when it's not featured - we just require a minimum quantity (typically one dozen pieces, or any cake) for any flavors that are not made during their featured month. Just give us a call if you'd like to order your favorite!

Month Cupcakes Cookie(s) Macaron(s) Ice Cream Sandwich(es)
JAN Angel Food
Carrot Pecan
Pecan Chocolate Chip Mocha
FEB Dark Chocolate Salted Caramel
Dark Chocolate Strawberry
Double Chocolate Chip Red Velvet
MAR Lemon Curd
Girl Scout Thin Mint
Oatmeal Peanut Butter
Salted Toffee Chocolate Chip
Passionfruit
Coconut
APR Strawberry Lemonade
Mocha White Chocolate Raspberry
Double Chocolate Chip
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Blackberry
Salted Caramel
Pink Macaron/Strawberry Ice Cream
MAY Black & White
Strawberries & Cream
Oatmeal Peanut Butter
Salted Toffee Chocolate Chip
Pistachio
Wedding Cake
Pink Macaron/Strawberry Ice Cream
JUN Lavender Honey Vanilla Bean
Mocha Caramel Kahlua
Pecan Chocolate Chip Lemon Chocolate Chip/Dark Chocolate Ice Cream
JUL Passionfruit Curd
Dark Chocolate Pistachio
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Wedding Cake Snickerdoodle/Peach Ice Cream
AUG White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Salted Dark Chocolate
Salted Toffee Chocolate Chip Coconut White Macaron/Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
SEP S'mores
Lemon Blackberry
Double Chocolate Chip
Oatmeal Peanut Butter
Tiramisu
Salted Caramel
Chocolate Chip/Dark Chocolate Ice Cream
OCT Pumpkin Spice
Tiramisu
Pecan Chocolate Chip
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Mocha
Pistachio
NOV Fig Mascarpone
Chocolate Hazelnut
Salted Toffee Chocolate Chip Blackberry
DEC Dark Chocolate Peppermint
Nutmeg Eggnog
Soft Gingerbread
Double Chocolate Chip
Red Velvet
Tiramisu

Coffee, Tea, and Other Drinks

We are so proud to serve Counter Culture Coffee to our customers!  Counter Culture sources incredible handmade coffees directly from farmers and cooperatives, going above and beyond to ensure environmental sustainability and fiscal prosperity for the entire coffee supply chain.  Counter Culture is fanatical about quality and is committed to sharing fresh, seasonally available coffees, keeping a low inventory of coffee beans and roasting to the peak of flavor and freshness.  

We prepare Counter Culture coffee blends brewed to order in individual Espro Presses and feature their single origin coffees brewed in a Chemex, for a clean, fruit-forward cup. We also serve Counter Culture espresso beans as part of our traditional Italian menu of coffee drinks.  All of our drink syrups are made fresh, by hand, in our Cream & Flutter kitchen, adding delicious notes of vanilla, chocolate, caramel to your coffee or hot chocolate experience.

When we found Bellocq Tea Atelier, we instantly fell in love with both their tea quality and their beautiful way of packaging and serving tea.  Bellocq sources whole, organic, loose leaf teas and we brew them to order, one cup or pot at a time, for each and every customer.  Bellocq makes drinking tea an almost poetic experience and we are happy to share this tradition with our Cream & Flutter tea fanatics!